People

Laura Shoemaker
Laura Shoemaker McGonagill
Senior Associate
Laura Shoemaker
Laura Shoemaker McGonagill
Senior Associate

Overview

A trial lawyer with hands-on advocacy experience beyond her years, Laura Shoemaker McGonagill excels at distilling complex disputes into coherent, understandable themes to present to juries, judges, and arbitrators. She approaches all stages of a dispute to best position her clients to tell their story. From taking and defending depositions of experts, corporate representatives, and fact witnesses, to arguing dispositive motions, and ultimately cross-examining and presenting witnesses at trial and in arbitration hearings, she makes the complicated simple. This approach, combined with her trial skills and experience, differentiates her from her peers.

What does this look like? It looks like securing summary judgment on contractual indemnity obligations intersecting multiple complicated agreements. It looks like convincing an arbitration panel to award tens of millions of dollars in the company’s favor through presentation of witnesses that told the company’s story. While the topics of each dispute differ, the key theme is the same: untangling complicated facts, agreements, or case law to convince the fact-finder of her client’s position.

Laura focuses her practice in two overarching sectors: energy and water. In the energy space, Laura works closely with oil and gas, power, and renewable energy clients on a broad range of issues involving disputes over leases, power purchase agreements, joint venture agreements, joint operating agreements, midstream agreements, master service agreements, and purchase and sale agreements, among others. In the water space, Laura has litigated various claims involving surface water, groundwater, and flood water, including claims under the Texas water code and nuisance and trespass disputes.  She has also represented clients in disputes over water permitting issues for the production and transportation of groundwater.

Laura proudly maintains an active pro bono practice and role in the community, serving on the Board of Wesley Community Center, receiving the 2023 Judge Thomas Gibbs Gee Award for Outstanding Pro Bono Service for her work to Eviscerate the Tampon Tax in Texas, and being named “Most Likely to Never Give Up” by Houston Volunteer Lawyers, the largest provider of pro bono legal services in Harris County, in its 2022-2023 Year in Review.

Admissions & Affiliations

  • State Bar of Texas

Education

  • J.D., The University of Texas School of Law 2017
    cum laude
  • B.A., Communication Studies, University of California, Los Angeles 2014
    cum laude
    College Honors

Experience

Energy Litigation

  • Secured multi-million arbitration award entirely in energy client’s favor, including full recovery of attorneys’ fees, in breach of contract dispute regarding offshore FPSO
  • Secured arbitration award entirely in renewable energy client’s favor, including full recovery of attorneys’ fees, in breach of contract dispute arising out of Winter Storm Uri
  • Represented non-operator in two international arbitrations (before ICC and UNCITRAL tribunals) against foreign operator on claims for improper charges to the joint account and various other accounting abuses in connection with onshore gas project in Africa
  • Defeated class certification in putative royalty class action involving nearly 4,000 royalty owners in Eagle Ford Shale (Regmund v. Talisman, No. 4:16-CV-02960, Southern District of Texas)
  • Represented national, publicly traded exploration and production corporation in dispute over ownership of produced water (CWS II Delaware, LLC v. Occidental Petroleum Corporation et al., No. 21-08-1041, 143rd Judicial District Court, Loving County, Texas)

Tort Litigation

  • Obtained summary judgment for publicly-traded upstream operator and its subsidiaries in multi-plaintiff consolidated case arising out of alleged community exposure to BTEX compounds (Cause No. C2017244; Josue Berlanga, et al vs. Barnett Gathering, LLC, et al., 355th Judicial District Court, Hood County, Texas)
  • Second-chaired arbitration hearing securing arbitration award entirely in client’s favor, including full recovery of attorneys’ fees, against contractor arising from fraudulent invoices (arbitration award confirmed in Shell Oil Company v. Innovative Turnaround Controls Ltd., No. 2020-74108, 189th Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas)
  • Lead associate in various personal injury matters with punitive damages at stake (e.g. Veronica Stephenson v. Southwestern Bell Telephone et al., No. 2018-45220, 133rd Judicial District Court, Harris County, Texas)

Diversion of Water/Flooding

  • Obtained summary judgment in Texas State court for global pipe manufacturer, defeating claims for trespass, negligence, nuisance, fraud, and water code violations related to construction of facility. (Winnie O’Connell et al. v. Tenaris Bay City Inc., Cause No. 19-E-0464, in the 130th Judicial District Court, Matagorda County, Texas)
  • Second-chaired trial to jury verdict in Texas state court in a negligence, nuisance, and breach of Texas water code lawsuit (Story et al. v. Tenaris Bay City Inc. et al., No. 2018-71970, 195th Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas)
  • Lead associate defending multi-defendant Class Action Lawsuit regarding various water diversion claims (Evans v. Enterprise Products Partners, LP et al., No. 2019-57694, 165th Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas)
  • Lead associate defending multi-plaintiff lawsuit alleging negligence, fraud, and breach of Texas water code (Garza et al. v. Magellan Midstream Partners LP, et al., No. 2021-25159, 189th Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas)
  • Lead associate defending Hurricane Harvey flood case, where plaintiffs allege breach of contract and breach of warranties due to flooding in construction of partially underground building in downtown Houston (Harris County, Texas v. Hoar Construction LLC, et al., No. 2020-57015, 157th Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas)

Pro Bono

  • Co-chaired bench trial to verdict in adverse possession case, securing judgment resulting in full victory for client (Will Jones, Jr. v. William Archie Armstrong et al., No. 2017-29377, 270th Judicial District Court, Harris County, Texas)
  • Represented tenants facing eviction in Harris county at weekly bench trials



Awards and Community

Listed as a "Leading Associate" in Energy Litigation: Oil & Gas by The Legal 500 U.S., 2025

Recognized as a Texas Super Lawyer - Rising Star (Thomson Reuters), 2024

Recipient, Judge Thomas Gibbs Gee Award for Outstanding Pro Bono Service, 2023